Build Your Own Pizza
Pizza with Two Toppings
$15.95
Pizza with Three Toppings
$16.80
Pizza with Four Toppings
$17.05
Sheet Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Please give a 24-hour notice before ordering.
$40.35
Single Topping Pizzas
Mozzarella Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$11.30
Anchovies Pizza
$12.40
Bacon Pizza
$12.40
Broccoli Pizza
$12.40
Chicken Pizza
$16.50
Clams Pizza
$14.05
Eggplant Pizza
$12.40
Ham Pizza
$12.40
Hamburger Pizza
$12.40
Mushrooms Pizza
$12.40
Olives Pizza
$12.40
Onions Pizza
$12.40
Pepperoni Pizza
$12.40
Peppers Pizza
$12.40
Sausage Pizza
$12.40
Spinach & Feta Pizza
$15.70
Specialty Pizza
Yianna's Pizza
Chicken, bacon, and BBQ sauce, with your choice of white or red sauce.
$16.80
Athenian Pizza
Eggplant, tomato, onion, feta, garlic.
$16.80
Clam Casino Pizza
Bacon, clams, and garlic, with your choice of red or white sauce.
$16.80
Margarita Pizza
With tomato & basil.
$15.70
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Your choice of red or white sauce.
$16.80
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Your choice of red or white sauce.
$16.80
White Pizza with Chicken, Broccoli & Garlic
$17.35
White Pizza with Feta, Tomato & Oregano
$16.50
White Pizza with Shrimp, Spinach & Garlic
$17.60
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Garlicky, butter shrimp with white sauce.
$17.60
Steak Pizza
Onions, peppers, mushrooms & mozzarella with your choice of red or white sauce.
$17.90
Greek Pizza
Tomato, onion, feta cheeses, olives, garlic, peppers, oregano.
$17.90
Hawaiian Pizza
Bacon or ham.
$15.70
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, ham & bacon.
$17.90
Moussaka Pizza
Eggplant & hamburger.
$15.70
House Special Pizza
Pepperoni, mushrooms, hamburger, peppers, onions, sausage.
$17.90
Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, broccoli.
$17.90
Appetizers
French Fries
$5.80
Coleslaw
$3.85
Onion Rings
$6.90
Fried Mozzarella
$11.00
Fried Chicken
$15.95
Chicken Fingers
$9.35
Chicken Fingers with Fries
$12.10
Chicken Wings
$16.50
Garlic Bread
With cheese & sauce.
$6.90
Seafood
Choice of clams, scallops, or shrimp.
$15.70
Side of Meatballs
$3.30
Side of Sausage
$3.30
Jalapeno Poppers
$11.00
Salads
Tossed Salad
$5.80
Greek Salad
Feta cheese, olives, pepperoncini.
$11.30
Antipasto Salad
Salami, ham, genoa, pepperoni, feta or mozzarella, olives, pepperoncini.
$18.15
Caesar Salad
$11.30
Buffalo Salad
$16.80
Tuna Salad
$14.60
Turkey Salad
$14.60
Grilled Chicken Salad
$16.25
Crispy Chicken Salad
$16.25
Sandwiches
Hamburger
$6.35
Cheeseburger
$6.60
Hot Dog
$5.80
Hot Dog with Fries
$11.55
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$4.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Tomato
$5.50
Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich
$8.80
Tuna Fish Sandwich
$9.65
Pastrami Sandwich
$10.45
Fish Sandwich
$10.45
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
$11.30
Turkey Sandwich
$10.45
Gyro Sandwich
Chicken or beef. Lettuce, tomato, onion, tzatziki sauce.
$11.00
Clam Roll with Cole Slaw
$14.60
BLT Sandwich
$9.65
Buffalo Wrap
Choice of grilled or fried chicken with buffalo sauce & bleu cheese dressing.
$11.55
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Lettuce, tomato & parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
$11.55
Club Sandwiches
Cheeseburger Club Sandwich
$17.90
Turkey Club Sandwich
$17.90
Ham Club Sandwich
$17.90
Sandwich Platters
Hamburger with French Fries & Pickle
$15.40
Hamburger with Cheese
$15.95
Hamburger with Bacon
$16.50
Gyro Platter
Lettuce, tomato, onion, and tzatziki sauce with French fries.
$17.60
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
With French fries & pickles.
$17.60
Fish Sandwich On A Bun
With French fries.
$17.60
Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich Platter
With French fries & pickles.
$15.95
Pastrami Sandwich
With French fries & pickles.
$17.60
Grinders
Cooked Salami Grinder
$9.10
Ham Grinder
$9.65
Genoa Salami Grinder
$9.65
Tuna Grinder
$10.20
Meatball Parmigiana Grinder
Comes with peppers and onions.
$9.65
Pepperoni Grinder
$9.90
Sausage Parmigiana Grinder
Comes with peppers and onions.
$9.65
Eggplant Grinder
$9.65
Pastrami Grinder
$9.90
Hamburger Grinder
$10.75
Veal Parmigiana Grinder
$11.55
Turkey Grinder
$10.75
Meatless Grinder
$9.65
Italian Combo Grinder
Salami, genoa, ham.
$11.85
Chicken Breast Filet Grinder
With parmigiana or mayo.
$11.55
Capicola Grinder
$9.65
Philly Steak Grinder
$11.85
Grilled Chicken Grinder
With mayo or parmigiana.
$11.85
Fish Grinder
$11.85
BLT Grinder
$11.55
Italian Flair
Chicken Breast Filet Parmesan
Chicken breast lightly breaded, smothered with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese, served with pasta.
$17.90
House Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Our house pasta in our delicious marinara sauce.
$14.60
House Pasta with Meatballs
$17.60
House Pasta with Sausage
$17.60
Fresh Veal Parmesan
Breaded veal with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese layered with pasta.
$20.35
Baked Lasagna
Layers of meat & cheese baked to perfection.
$17.90
Ravioli with Zesty Marinara Sauce
Stuffed pockets of pasta served with zesty marinara sauce.
$17.35
Ravioli with Meat Sauce
Stuffed pockets of pasta served with meat sauce.
$17.35
House Pasta with Mushrooms
Our house pasta is tossed with sauteed mushrooms. Your choice of marinara or meat sauce.
$16.80
Eggplant Parmesan with Marinara
Thin slices of breaded eggplant baked with mozzarella cheese & served with pasta.
$20.10
Eggplant Parmesan with Meat Sauce
Thin slices of breaded eggplant baked with mozzarella cheese & served with pasta.
$20.10
Stuffed Shells with Marinara Sauce
Pasta shells stuffed with ricotta cheese & smothered with marinara sauce.
$16.80
Stuffed Shells with Meat Sauce
Pasta shells stuffed with ricotta cheese & smothered with meat sauce.
$16.80
Shrimp Scampi
A generous portion of shrimp lightly sauteed with garlic served with our house pasta.
$22.00
Moussaka Dinner
Layers of eggplant and a savory meat sauce baked to perfection, served with our house pasta.
$22.00
Seafood
Fried Shrimp
Lightly breaded & fried to perfection.
$21.20
Fried Clams
Lightly breaded strips of native clams fried to golden perfection.
$19.80
Fresh Baked Haddock
Perfectly baked haddock served with your choice of French fries, house pasta, or shells.
$22.00
Seafood Platter
An inviting combination of haddock, fried clams, bay scallops & shrimp.
$33.00
Fish & Chips
Lightly battered haddock fried to a golden brown served with French fries.
$16.80
Fried Bay Scallops
$22.00
Favorites
Fried Chicken
Crispy, hand-breaded chicken fried to golden perfection, served with french fries.
$22.00
Kid's Menu
Kid's Spaghetti with Butter Sauce
$8.80
Kid's Spaghetti with Sauce
$8.80
Kid's Shells with Butter Sauce
$8.80
Kid's Shells with Sauce
$8.80
Kid's Grilled Cheese with French Fries
$9.35
Kid's Chicken Fingers with French Fries
$9.90
Kid's Fish & Chips
$12.10
Kid's Ravioli
$9.90
Desserts
Rice Pudding
Old fashioned baked rice pudding.
$5.50
Tiramisu
$4.70
Cheesecake
$4.95
Beverages
Soda
$3.25
Water
$3.05
Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace
Up for some mouthwatering pie near you in Old Lyme, CT? Look no further than Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace! What makes us one of the best pizzerias in the neighborhood is our excellent food and service. Plus, we strive to be consistent with the level of our quality, so you can be assured that a great dining experience awaits you every single time. Wondering what's on our menu? Well, our pizza selection is always a great place to start. You can try our mozzarella cheese pie, or even create yours with up to four toppings. In addition, we offer a number of gourmet and specialty pizzas. The former include options like our Hawaiian, Meat Lovers, and veggie pie. Whereas the latter have our Margarita, BBQ chicken, and steak pizza, to name a few. Furthermore, we serve different appetizers, salads, sandwiches, grinders, dinners, seafood, desserts, and others. As for our youngest visitors, we provide an awesome kid's menu as well. Oh, and, if you have an upcoming event or special occasion, you should definitely check out our catering services, too. You're welcome to stop by for lunch or dinner at our cozy restaurant. Or you can also order us for pickup on Slice, and we'll have your food prepared for you!
Full Hours